Forward | No Sadness.

I’ve cried wolf before, I know. Except this time it’s really over: I’ve left Lightroom for Capture One.

To be fair I went through the same on again/off again period before switching from Aperture to Lightroom, so it’s pretty much par for the course. The truth is, these moves are incredibly hard in terms of logistics, the amount of time involved etc. You need a strategy that makes sense, you need to figure out the best workflow for the new setup, get a handle on the’s just a huge undertaking.

I already had a foot in the door thanks to the master catalog solution I wrote about last year, so all I needed was a final nudge...and Adobe obliged with Lightroom CC Classic.

Are you f#&@ kidding me???

I’m ok with subscriptions. I don’t love them and it does force me to take a long hard look at any piece of software that chooses this route...but I’m not opposed to the basic principle of it. When Ulysses announced their switch to a subscription model, I experienced about four seconds of doubt before hitting purchase—even though I was given a loyalty grace period. That’s because Ulysses is an app that 1) delights me on a daily basis and 2) makes my work so much easier that it unquestionably pays for itself. And as far as I’m concerned they’ve already fulfilled their promise of ongoing development with a couple of absolutely stellar updates in a short amount of time. Seriously, the last update for iOS 11 is a game changer for me. When Adobe introduced CC they also touted how the change would allow this non-stop flurry of continuous improvements. We would win. So much winning. I bought into it, eventually.
What a load of BS.

Instead of innovation that matters, we got zilch, missteps and bugs. Now, adding insult to injury, we have Lightroom CC. No, not that Lightroom CC, a brand NEW one. has machine learning...but no curves. Who needs curves right? Photographers? Pfff. And then we have Lightroom CC Mobile...which a) used to just be known as Lightroom Mobile, b) is the exact same app as before and c) has none of the machine learning stuff. Adobe just likes labeling anything CC. Lightroom CC is now of course Lightroom CC Classic—because that makes total sense and because classic is such a historically great moniker for ANY product: right off the bat it inspires confidence and positively screams FUTURE!

Seriously, what crazy intern was promoted to head of marketing on this one?

And to top it all off, Lightroom CC (the new one, not the old one) sends all our files to Adobe servers. Not a culled selection mind you but all of ‘em, no opting out. Storage space you say? Bah...don’t you worry your purty little head now darlin’. We’ll make you a deal. Don’t sweat’s all goooood.

Right. I know this is all old news by now—but for me it was the final straw. I was in a blur of magazine editing, finalizing a conference on the side but I looked up from the fog that morning and thought: nope. I never liked Adobe and now I absolutely do not trust them one. single. bit. The fact that Lightroom Classic actually IS way faster...well, that’s almost an insult in my book. Because they could’ve done it before but didn’t. Because they’d much rather figure out a way to eek out more money from users. Because who the hell calls a supposedly active product Classic??? Call it Desktop for god’s sake. Ceding the official app name to a glorified version of Photos is telling. I don’t care how they spin it.


The technology landscape is thriving. We’re seeing small companies blowing away what huge behemoths barely manage to accomplish—Affinity Photo on iOS (I haven’t tried the Mac version) puts Adobe to shame. I’m waiting with bated breath for the upcoming Pixelmator Pro—its UI alone makes Photoshop look like a Model T (and if features work as All These new companies are leveraging built-in APIs Adobe doesn’t even appear to be aware of—and it shows. Luminar 2018...OnOne Photo Raw...the barbarians are at the gates and it’s exciting.

What now?

I’ve exported all my edited images and moved all work to C1. I was already comfortable with the app but I watched a bunch of webinars, learned some new tricks, took some notes and revisited my entire environment to fine-tune any outstanding issues. I’ll be purchasing Pixelmator Pro when it’s released on November 29 to replace Photoshop (I’ve done it before and actually miss it); if I’m not satisfied Affinity is another option. Because that’s the takeaway: we have options.

Will these moves simplify my workflow? Not really. It’s actually making everything slightly more complex—GFX files alone require a measure of voodoo magic for C1. The truth is I could keep on using Lightroom without a hitch...I just don’t want to anymore. Simple as that.

Five years ago I wrote an official “I’m leaving Aperture for Lightroom” post entitled Forward | Sadness. Excitement. Moving On. Today I do it again.
Minus the sadness.